Response 146898080

Back to Response listing

About you

3. What is your name?

Name
Jill Stewart

Individual respondents

6. Are you completing this call for views on behalf of yourself, or someone else?

Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Ticked Yourself
Radio button: Unticked Someone else

9. Please indicate your agreement with the following statement, from 1 = strongly disagree, to 5 = strongly agree

I have/the person I represent has faced issues with taking part in sport or physical activity as a woman or girl 1 - Strongly disagree Radio button: Not checked 1 - Strongly disagree I have/the person I represent has faced issues with taking part in sport or physical activity as a woman or girl 2 - Disagree Radio button: Not checked 2 - Disagree I have/the person I represent has faced issues with taking part in sport or physical activity as a woman or girl 3 - Neither agree or disagree Radio button: Not checked 3 - Neither agree or disagree I have/the person I represent has faced issues with taking part in sport or physical activity as a woman or girl 4 - Agree Radio button: Not checked 4 - Agree I have/the person I represent has faced issues with taking part in sport or physical activity as a woman or girl 5 - Strongly agree Radio button: Checked 5 - Strongly agree
Please give further details if you wish:
I was badly injured in a mixed sex basketball game whilst at university when I collided with a male player. This injury ended my participation in elite sports.

Question page 1

14. What issues, if any, affect women and girls taking part in community sport and physical activity?

Please provide your response in the box.
Women are constrained by their biology in ways that men are not - for example, physical performance is linked to our menstrual cycle. At community level, this can explain why women and girls will pick-up unexpected injuries or have a 'bad' session, but it is rarely discussed or widely known.

15. How might these challenges be overcome?

Please provide your response in the box.
At the very least, women and girls need safe, secure and private changing facilities. Above all else, facilities where women and girls are undressed must always be single sex.

Question page 2

16. What issues, if any, affect women and girls taking part in elite sport?

Please provide your response in the box.
In my experience, it was very difficult to find a good coach - this was 20 years ago, and female athletes were treated like small men rather than different people with different needs. Viewed from this perspective, female sports is regarded as being 'lesser' than male sports and this attitude persists today (professional sportswomen earn less than sportsmen). There is consequently less encouragement, less support and less infrastructure for females.

17. How might these challenges be overcome?

Please provide your response in the box.
The principle of fairness should be paramount in sports, otherwise what is the point? We become a bunch of overgrown children, still playing silly games. Fairness means that the integrity of female sports should be protected, and participation in competitions should be restricted to those who are born female.

Question page 3

18. What additional issues, if any, affect women and girls from marginalised groups taking part in sport or physical activity?

Please provide your response in the box.
Finding accessible and affordable childcare.

19. How might these challenges be overcome?

Please provide your response in the box.
Having adult specific fitness/sporting events running in parallel with sports for kids in community of leisure centres. For example - a kids swimming club in one room while the Mum's play basketball in the other.

Question page 4

20. Do you have any further comments?

Please provide your response in the box.
The health and safety concerns of allowing male born people to complete in female sports are real and significant and must not be dismissed. If the goal is to increase female participation, then the safety and dignity of women and girls must be prioritised.