Response 269116042

Back to Response listing

About you

What is your name?

Name (Required)
Anthony Perkins

Overall views

What are your overall views on the Scottish Government’s plans to restrict the sale and use of certain types of fireworks and pyrotechnic articles in Scotland, as set out in the Bill?

Please provide your response in the box provided.
I would prefer it if the noisier ones were kept to new year's eve and bonfire night, Diwali and Chinese New Years celebrations and lower noise F2 and F3 fireworks were permitted at other times of the year.

This way, you can still allow all year sales but it's less of a nuisance outside the main seasons and less stress on people and animals and less shock value if lower noise fireworks were only allowed outside the times I mention.

Types of fireworks covered by licensing system

What are your views on this proposal?

Please provide your response in the box provided.
Licensing for private displays is futile as it would unfairly target responsible people and would jeopardize scout groups brownies guides school PTAs churches clubs pubs and societies from holding fireworks events for their members and regulars.

Restrictions on supply of fireworks

What are your views on the proposed restricted periods on which CAT F2 and CAT F3 fireworks can be purchased by the public?

Please provide your response in the box provided.
It would be better if low noise fireworks and reduced noise fireworks were sold outside the main times to reduce nuisance.

Restrictions on the use of fireworks

What are your views on the proposed changes to the days on which fireworks can be used?

Please provide your response in the box provided.
Like I've said, only limits on the noisy fireworks being sold at the regular festival times and quieter ones outside those periods would strike a sensible balance between pleasure and nuisance.

Criminal offences

What are your views on these new criminal offences?

Please provide your response in the box provided.
It's a very good idea but the police need to enforce this better with local trading standards also involved too.

Compensation scheme for businesses

What are your views on a proposed compensation scheme?

Please provide your response in the box provided.
It's a good idea should the bill without my recommendations go ahead.

Firework Control Zones

What are your views on the proposals for Firework Control Zones?

Please provide your response in the box provided.
It would be fruitless without heavy strict enforcement

Restrictions at certain designated places or events

What are your views on the restrictions of the use of fireworks and pyrotechnic articles at certain events, and the restricted use of pyrotechnic articles more generally?

Please provide your response in the box provided
Flares and F2 / F3 fireworks shouldn't be permitted at such events anyway

Other issues

Those issues which the Scottish Government proposes to deal with in regulations after the Bill has been passed into law? (Set out in the Delegated Powers Memorandum)

Please provide your response in the box provided
None

Are there any other issues you think the Bill should address relating to the use of fireworks or pyrotechnic articles?

Please provide your response in the box provided.
None